Nina Dobrev and Shaun White are taking their relationship to the next level after five years of dating.

The Vampire Diaries star, 34, and the former Olympic snowboarder, 36, announced they were engaged on Wednesday, sharing photos on social media of White’s epic proposal under an arch of white roses.

“RIP boyfriend, hello fiancé,” Dobrev wrote in an Instagram post that included a moment of a hug in which White catches her off guard. On his own page, White shared a photo of himself on one knee and wrote, “She said YES.”

The couple also opened up about the relationship milestone in an interview with Fashionin which White revealed that the proposal was a long time coming – it just took him a while to find the perfect moment. To ensure a surprise, White hatched an elaborate plan, enlisting Dobrev’s publicist to send her a fake invitation to cocktail hour with Anna Wintour.

“He made the invite look so legitimate,” Dobrev said with a laugh. But instead of arriving for an intimate evening with the fashion icon, Dobrev entered the restaurant to find White in a candlelit room with a photographer and hundreds of white roses.

“I went into shock,” Dobrev recalls. “I just froze and stared at him.”

When she finally went over to meet him in the middle, White immediately tensed her nerves. “When she’s nervous, she jokes,” he said. “She says, ‘So wait, Anna’s not here?'”

At that point, Dobrev had essentially blacked out, though she does remember White nailing his proposal speech. “He said all the right things,” the actress recalled. While they initially chose to keep the news within their inner circle, Dobrev has since grown tired of leaving her engagement ring at home, adding, “I don’t want to take it off anymore.”

The actress and the athlete first sparked dating rumors in 2020 when they were spotted cycling together in Malibu. They became Instagram official two months later — thanks to Dobrev giving White a quarantine haircut — and later revealed that their relationship began in 2019 and led to them moving in together at the start of the coronavirus pandemic.

Sign up for Entertainment weekly‘s free daily newsletter with breaking TV news, exclusive first looks, recaps, reviews, interviews with your favorite stars and more.

Last year, White hinted at the possibility of a future engagement while chatting with PEOPLE. “We’re just enjoying our time together now. No pressure,” he told the outlet in May. “But I told her, ‘Look, after the Olympics I finally got the freedom to do anything. And let’s just have fun and be together and support each other.'”

White, who retired from competing after the 2022 Winter Olympics in Beijing, added: “But you never know. We’ll see what happens.”