Lindsay Lohan had the perfect joke for the Disney CEO during the Parent trap premiere on the red carpet.

The 38-year-old actress recalled a moment from the 1998 event, when she was 12 years old, while performing in Watch What Happens live with Andy Cohen Wednesday, November 20 next Mean girls costar Lacey Chabert, 42.

The Our little secret star revealed that then-Disney CEO Michael Eisner walked up to her at the premiere and asked, “Where’s your twin brother?”

Lohan – who played both Hallie and Annie, separated at birth, in the comedy – recalled mentioning her Parent trap salary in her answer.

“I was so young I don’t even know how I thought I said this, but I will never forget what I said. I said, ‘Well, you should have paid me double because I don’t have one!’ Lohan recalled that he was supposed to host Cohen, 56.

When Cohen heard Lohan’s response, he gave Lohan a high five, while Chabert could be heard responding with a surprised “Oh!”

Lohan’s response has been praised WWHL‘s Instagram page this week. One commenter wrote: “’You should have paid me double’ is my mantra and I don’t even play twins.” Another person exclaimed that Lohan “was a star from the start.”

Never miss a story: Sign up for PEOPLE’s free daily newsletter to stay up-to-date on the best of what PEOPLE has to offer, from celebrity news to compelling human interest stories.

On WWHLCohen also asked Lohan, “What’s the most popular role that you didn’t end up getting and that no one knows you even auditioned for?” Fans on Instagram described her response as ‘iconic’.

Lohan responded, “I mean, the first movie I auditioned for was The parent trap, and I haven’t auditioned since.”

Lohan’s latest role is in Netflix’s Christmas rom-com Our little secret, also featuring Kristin Chenoweth, Ian Harding, Jon Rudnitsky, Dan Bucatinsky and Mean girls costar Tim Meadows.

The actress previously told PEOPLE what these holiday films mean to viewers and how they make her feel.

“I have been fortunate to see them become part of families’ traditions,” Lohan said, “and I still get so much joy from being part of something that can uplift people during such a special time of year .”

Our little secret is on Netflix November 27.