Cynthia Erivo has always kept her private life private. As a result, details about her past relationships are few and far between. However, we do know that the Broadway superstar was romantically involved with British actor Dean John-Wilson in 2013. The Guardianthe duo reportedly first crossed paths when they worked together on the stage production of Sister Act.

The couple made their red carpet debut in 2016, when Wilson starred as Aladdin in Disney’s West End production, per BBC news. But by 2017, they had quietly gone their separate ways for reasons that remain unclear.

That same year, Erivo started dating Mario Martinez. In an interview with Vanity fair‘, she revealed: ‘He chased me.’ Martinez wasn’t in the industry, but their paths crossed often. He asked her out every time, even when she was with her ex, Wilson.

“The last time I was away from my ex, except this time he didn’t ask for it,” Erivo remembers. “He just walked up to me and gave me a kiss.” At the time of the interview, Erivo and Martinez had been together for two years.