The Buffalo Bills’ Josh Allen has long been considered an “alien” quarterback. He showed off some of his particularly unique talents during Monday night’s game against the New York Jets on a play that drew a strong reaction from legendary quarterback Peyton Manning.

On ESPN’s ManningCastPeyton was watching a Bills play with his brother Eli and Bill Belichick when he appeared to try to warn Allen through the screen. One second and ten deep in Bills territory, Allen dropped back into his end zone and then scrambled to the sideline looking for a pass downfield.

“Throw it away, throw it away,” Peyton repeated, fear evident in his voice.

Allen finally threw it – about 40 yards downfield, to Bills running back Ray Davis, who made an equally insane grab.

The officials threw a defensive holding flag, upholding the game.

Peyton Manning couldn’t believe his eyes.

“It’s amazing how late he waits, he gets almost out of bounds… and he throws it, he can throw it as far as he wants,” Peyton said.

Allen has currently thrown for 112 yards and two passing touchdowns and added one touchdown on the ground. At halftime, the Bills are up 20-17.