Max’s The penguin has finally premiered its finale, bringing a fitting end to all the main characters’ arcs. Aside from Colin Farrell’s masterful portrayal of the titular villain, Cristin Milioti’s Sofia is the one who completely stole the spotlight for her powerful storyline. However, her harrowing fate at the end of The Penguin has left fans with heavy hearts for the tragic character. Still, the finale introduced an element that teased a potential collaboration between Sofia and Zoe Kravitz’s Selina Kyle. In a recent discussion, Cristin Milioti addressed this development, suggesting a possible meeting between the two half-sisters in The Batman 2.

Cristin Milioti teases Selina Kyle and Sofia’s team after The Penguin finale

Milioti revealed that she is actively hoping to return as the unhinged but troubled gangster in Matt Reeves’ Batman sequel. She also stated that a possible truce between Sofia and her on-screen half-sister Selina Kyle could lead to explosive results in Gotham.

The How I Met Your Mother actress gave her thoughts on her future in Reeves’ Batman universe during an interview with The Direct. While talking about her return as Sofia in future DC projects, Milioti also gave her thoughts on the proposed team-up between her character and Selina Kyle, aka Catwoman.

“I mean, it’s my wildest hope that I can revisit her because I’ve loved this role so much. It’s one of my favorite things I’ve ever done, and I’m just obsessed with her,” Milioti said.

“And I think if (Sofia and Selina Kyle) were united, we would really tear it up. I don’t know how to put it… We’d just like to burn it down. You know what I mean? In a fun way. I think we would have a lot of fun,” she added.

Milioti also suggested that if a collaboration were to happen, it would be the two taking on both the Penguin and Batman.

In the final moments of The Penguin, Milioti’s Sofia receives a mysterious letter after she unceremoniously returns to Arkham Asylum. Soon after, viewers learn that the person responsible for sending the note is none other than Selina Kyle.

The Batman Part 2 will be released in theaters on October 2, 2026.